Select Language



No match found


No match found


No match found


No match found


No match found


No match found


No match found


No match found

Exploring North America’s Critical Minerals Advantage: Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference

  •  Minute Read Clock/
  • ListenListen/ StopStop/
  • Text Bigger | Text Smaller Text


Can North America become a leader in critical minerals mining? That’s a question that was explored by a panel of industry experts at BMO’s 32nd annual Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference.

Moderated by BMO Financial Group Chief Sustainability Officer Michael Torrance, the panel saw the question tackled by Remi Piet, Co-founder and Senior Partner at Embellie Advisory, Eugene Lei, Senior Vice-President and Chief Financial Officer at Hudbay Minerals, and Jeff Hanman, Senior Vice-President of Sustainability and External Affairs at Teck Resources Limited.

Michael Torrance opened the panel with a conference poll showing that 61 percent of respondents agree that North America is falling behind other major resource regions in accelerating the production of critical minerals feedstock. The question for the panelists was whether they agreed, or, if not, why?

Panelists agreed that with demand for critical minerals like lithium, graphite, copper, and rare earths rapidly increasing, North America must do more to become a strategic supplier of these up-and-coming commodities.

“We have developed world-class governance systems and sustainability standards, but how do you turn that into a competitive advantage?” said Eugene Lei, whose diversified Canadian mining company primarily produces critical minerals copper and zinc, as well as gold, and applies Canada’s Towards Sustainable Mining (TSM) standards across its operations, globally.

Embracing ESG

In Lei’s view, North America’s advantage lies in its commitment to environmental, social and governance (ESG) practices and its ability to source materials in sustainable ways that benefit the people and areas companies are in. “It’s critical to align yourself into the social and economic fabric of the communities where you operate,” he said. “So, the opportunity to achieve premium pricing for materials lies in producing them in a more ethical and socially responsible way.”

Hudbay Minerals, as part of its commitment to sustainability, is also looking for ways to keep production chains for its North American operations within the continent. At a new project in Arizona, the company plans to both mine and produce cathode copper for the U.S. supply chain in the same place. “That’s something that people are demanding and by the end of this decade it’s going to be critical for us to have that sort of premium product out there, to reduce our operational GHG footprint as well as benefit from not having to spend $750 million over the life of mine to ship these products (overseas) for processing,” he said.

Better Access to Resources

Remi Piet, whose firm helps international investors in mining and other projects in the Americas and other regions, said North America currently has three strategic advantages over other nations: access to resources, financial capacity to develop mines and operations, and the technological capacity to innovate. But he also said that other parts of the world, such as Saudi Arabia and Europe, will catch up, especially in the latter two areas.

If Canada and the U.S. are going to get ahead, they must do a better job of developing their resources, which are fairly extensive, said Piet, especially when it comes to lithium, nickel, and other in-demand battery-related materials. “The question is much more in terms of access to resources,” he explained. “The lack of investment into undeveloped pipeline projects as well as greenfield developments over the last few decades has clearly limited the capacity of North America to develop and produce minerals compared to other regions.”

The trend may be turning, he said, especially in the U.S, where the recently passed Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) is creating incentives for people to buy electric vehicles (EVs) and for companies to manufacture EVs in the U.S. “The IRA has created strong appeal for the entire sector to settle in North America,” he said, pointing out that battery company Northvolt is now considering allocating resources once earmarked for Europe to the U.S.

Faster Permitting

Plentiful resources, political stability and a strong infrastructure is what Jeff Hanman said gives North America its competitive advantage, but it has one major challenge it must overcome before it can become a critical minerals leader: permitting. Companies are struggling with “getting access to these resources in a timely fashion,” he explained.

Part of the problem is that while ESG factors are driving demand for critical minerals, the same forces can constrain supply, making access to resources more complex as companies need to mine in more sustainable ways. “If you’re trying to decarbonize rapidly, you need the supply, otherwise it will become too expensive to do anything in a reasonable timeline,” he said. “But at the same time, governments and the public want those minerals, but they expect them with far less impact than we’ve seen historically. That’s a real challenge for companies to both increase supply and do it in a way that has less impact.”

It’s a conundrum that can only be solved with innovation and finding ways to produce more minerals with fewer carbon emissions. Hanman is encouraged, however, by the number of companies seeking to build more nature-positive mining operations, which involves not only reducing emissions, but increasing biodiversity at the same time. Teck Resources is one company that has committed to becoming nature positive, which it’s doing to improve the world, and to meet rising regulator and stakeholder expectations.

“When you approach a resource development project, most of the concerns that local communities have are related to potential impacts on the environment. If you can find ways to mitigate those credibly at the outset, that has the potential to unlock some of the permitting challenges and really capture the advantage that North America inherently has.”

Clean Energy Opportunity

The panel focused on the experience of North America’s capital markets industry in mining and metals finance, and how the finance sector is collaborating with the industry to develop credible ESG standards that alleviate the onus on banks and investors to evaluate for themselves companies’ ESG performance. They agreed that having this close collaboration between the capital markets and industry can create an advantage for Canada and the U.S.

The differentiation potential in the U.S. and Canada through low-carbon mining was also discussed. The two countries produce metals and minerals with approximately 30 percent lower GHG emissions than other resource-rich nations, one panelist noted. Between the two countries, however, Canada has a slightly higher emissions intensity for its mining assets on average than the U.S., which at first blush may seem surprising given the cleaner grid. This higher footprint is due to the many remote mines dotted across the country, which therefore require the use of higher-emitting energy sources. To rapidly advance both countries’ competitive advantage for low-carbon products, they must invest more in clean energy generation, transmission, and distribution, including distributed energy systems.

A National Strategy

Ultimately, to fully realize North America’s competitive advantage, the continent needs national or even regional strategies for critical minerals mining. The panel highlighted Australia as an example. The country overlays resource development hotspots with environmentally sensitive areas along with locations at a higher risk of community engagement issues and regulatory challenges. This strategy has allowed companies to expedite resource development by prioritizing lower-risk areas.

BMO’s Climate Institute conducted a similar exercise that looked across North America for development hot spots, critical habitats, and areas that were more at risk for social and regulatory issues, which identifies lower-risk areas that could be prioritized. 

Ultimately, if companies are going to tap into North America’s abundant resources, and do it in a timely manner, they’ll need to work with more diverse stakeholders and Indigenous rights holders, said Piet. “There’s an evolution we’re seeing in terms of integrating more and different stakeholders into projects,” he noted. “A national resource development strategy will still require consensus at a local level and create a deeper understanding between project developers and stakeholders to mitigate the prevalent not-in-my-backyard issue. Building that consensus, including through robust ESG frameworks, will help you transform the mining sector by bringing these more innovative projects to fruition.”

Read more
Michael Torrance Chief Sustainability Officer


Mining Market Pivot on the Horizon

Dan Barclay February 27, 2023

  “We’ve managed through some very difficult periods, the pandemic, the tragic war in Ukraine and the impact of all of that on su…


Will 2023 be the Year of Gold: World Gold Council at BMO Conference

March 01, 2023

  If last year was the year of the dollar, 2023 may be a year that gold starts to gain momentum, especially if the World Gold Council’s…


Evolving Mining for a Sustainable Energy Transition: ICMM CEO Rohitesh Dhawan in Conversation

Dan Barclay March 02, 2023

  “The world has woken up to the scale of our biodiversity crisis. And if we don’t urgently stop and halt and reverse the loss of…


The Most Valuable Commodity is Trust: ICMM to BMO Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference

March 06, 2023

  At a time when the global mining industry is looking to meet growing demand, the first keynote speaker at BMO’s 32nd annual Global Me…


Rock Legends Reflect on Mining Hits and Misses: Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference

March 06, 2023

  It’s not every day that four mining industry legends get together to talk about the state of their sector. But at this year’s G…


Energy Transition Will Require Collaboration Between Miners and End-Users

Colin Hamilton March 06, 2023

  With electric vehicle (EV) demand increasing the need for critical minerals, mining companies, auto manufacturers and other industry player…


Not All Carbon Credits Created Equal: BMO Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference

March 06, 2023

  As more mining companies expand their focus beyond what they are pulling out of the ground to what they are putting into the air, there wil…


Exploring Risk and Opportunity in ESG Ratings in Mining

Jonathan Hackett, Doug A. Morrow March 06, 2023

  Nowhere is the growth in environmental, social and governance (ESG) reporting more evident than it is in the mining sector. Still, accordin…


BMO Experts at our 32nd Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference

March 03, 2023

  “At BMO, the nature of our client base drives our strategic decision-making, and each year we look to innovate and improve our annual…


Global Metals & Mining 32nd Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference

Feb. 26, 2023 - March 1, 2023 Hollywood, Florida

Email Us

You might also be interested in