Respecting Indigenous Rights In The Low Carbon Economy Transition
-
bookmark
-
print
Indigenous People make up less than 5% of the world population, but protect close to 80% of the planet’s biodiversity and own, occupy, or use 25% of the world’s surface area. To reach the goals of the Paris Agreement by 2050, we need rapid expansion of the renewable energy industry, as well as increased mining for minerals. These could come at a cost often bared by the indigenous groups – for example, land title issues and destruction of habitats. Therefore, the energy transition needs to be done in partnership with, and not negatively affect, indigenous communities and land stewards.
However, the Business and Human Rights Centre’s Renewable Energy & Human Rights benchmark found that the renewable energy industry on average scored less than 1 out of 6 points on their commitments to respect the rights of indigenous peoples and affected communities, and on their approaches to respecting land rights.
A social contract requires consent
The theme for this year’s commemoration of the International Day of the World’s Indigenous Peoples is “redesigning the social contract”, where Indigenous People’s own ways of governance and life are respected and based on their free, prior and informed consent (FPIC).
As investors, we expect companies with land-based operations to commit to upholding FPIC to ensure indigenous communities consent to operations on or near their land – to mitigate risk to people and business, as well as to identify opportunities for mutual benefit. FPIC should be the premise of any business decision that would have a negative impact on local stakeholders, not the other way round. A hopeful best practice emerging in Canada on the opportunity side of things is the creation of partnerships between companies and indigenous communities, whereby the community owns a direct equity stake in the project. Such partnerships aide economic reconciliation with indigenous communities, and establish better social contracts that are mutually beneficial.
Commitments versus practice
Although the Renewable Energy & Human Rights benchmark also found that most companies have basic commitments to FPIC in place, unfortunately policy commitments do not readily translate to good practice on the ground – as was demonstrated in 2020 when mining companies Rio Tinto and BHP destroyed an Aboriginal cultural heritage site at Juukan Gorge in Australia, a tragedy that could have been easily prevented. In order to ensure that this type of harm to indigenous people and culture does not happen again, investors need to have a better understanding of the underlying practices and indicators of strong FPIC.
At BMO Global Asset Management, we have been engaging companies in the energy, mining and renewable energy sectors this year to encourage more transparency around the implementation of respect for indigenous rights. We have identified that at a minimum, companies need to have human rights due diligence processes in place, conduct human rights impact assessments at the site or project level and commit to respect the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.
Diving deeper
What other information can investors ask from investee companies, particularly those in the extractives and energy sectors, to understand how robust their public commitments to respecting indigenous rights are in practice? Here are ten questions we have found helpful in our own engagements with companies:
-
How are concerns from affected communities escalated to the top, and does senior management and the board have responsibility for and oversight of indigenous relationships?
-
What type of expert advice does the board and senior management take into account to inform them of good practice, such as an external advisory committee consisting of indigenous representatives?
-
How does the company identify indigenous persons and how does it discern what constitutes customary, ancestry, or collective land, territories, cultural heritage and resources in each project area?
-
How often is FPIC reviewed and renewed? What is the company’s contingency plan if FPIC wasn’t granted, or would the company still proceed as usual assuming FPIC is a soft requirement? Once agreements between the company and communities or titleholders are signed, how does the company ensure there is ongoing project-based consultation and consent?
-
What does the company and the community define as consent, and with whom has consent been secured? Are there any groups (neighbouring, or otherwise) which have not consented?
-
Do the contracts contain any elements that would prohibit titleholders from speaking out publicly in cases of discontent?
-
Is the company able to provide transparency into contracts with indigenous communities or disclose them in full, and if not, why? (i.e. a good reason would be that the indigenous communities do not want contracts to be made public)
-
Can the company provide insight into grievance cases and the actions it has taken to provide remedy?
-
How does the company work with the local authority to respect indigenous rights when lands are not officially titled to the local indigenous groups?
-
How does the company incorporate benefits-sharing with communities explicitly into its projects?
Final thoughts
With any best practice related to minimising harm of affected people, what constitutes robust FPIC and a good relationship with indigenous communities should be informed by what indigenous communities themselves identify as being best practice.
Interested in learning more? For further reading, we would recommend:
First People’s Worldwide’s FPIC Due Diligence Questionnaire
Understanding Successful Approaches of FPIC in Canada
Respecting Indigenous Rights In The Low Carbon Economy Transition
Vice President, Responsible Investment Analyst
Rosa van den Beemt is a corporate engagement practitioner with over 6 years’ experience in the responsible investment industry and joined the Responsible Inve…
Rosa van den Beemt is a corporate engagement practitioner with over 6 years’ experience in the responsible investment industry and joined the Responsible Inve…
VIEW FULL PROFILE- Minute Read
- Listen Stop
- Text Bigger | Text Smaller
Indigenous People make up less than 5% of the world population, but protect close to 80% of the planet’s biodiversity and own, occupy, or use 25% of the world’s surface area. To reach the goals of the Paris Agreement by 2050, we need rapid expansion of the renewable energy industry, as well as increased mining for minerals. These could come at a cost often bared by the indigenous groups – for example, land title issues and destruction of habitats. Therefore, the energy transition needs to be done in partnership with, and not negatively affect, indigenous communities and land stewards.
However, the Business and Human Rights Centre’s Renewable Energy & Human Rights benchmark found that the renewable energy industry on average scored less than 1 out of 6 points on their commitments to respect the rights of indigenous peoples and affected communities, and on their approaches to respecting land rights.
A social contract requires consent
The theme for this year’s commemoration of the International Day of the World’s Indigenous Peoples is “redesigning the social contract”, where Indigenous People’s own ways of governance and life are respected and based on their free, prior and informed consent (FPIC).
As investors, we expect companies with land-based operations to commit to upholding FPIC to ensure indigenous communities consent to operations on or near their land – to mitigate risk to people and business, as well as to identify opportunities for mutual benefit. FPIC should be the premise of any business decision that would have a negative impact on local stakeholders, not the other way round. A hopeful best practice emerging in Canada on the opportunity side of things is the creation of partnerships between companies and indigenous communities, whereby the community owns a direct equity stake in the project. Such partnerships aide economic reconciliation with indigenous communities, and establish better social contracts that are mutually beneficial.
Commitments versus practice
Although the Renewable Energy & Human Rights benchmark also found that most companies have basic commitments to FPIC in place, unfortunately policy commitments do not readily translate to good practice on the ground – as was demonstrated in 2020 when mining companies Rio Tinto and BHP destroyed an Aboriginal cultural heritage site at Juukan Gorge in Australia, a tragedy that could have been easily prevented. In order to ensure that this type of harm to indigenous people and culture does not happen again, investors need to have a better understanding of the underlying practices and indicators of strong FPIC.
At BMO Global Asset Management, we have been engaging companies in the energy, mining and renewable energy sectors this year to encourage more transparency around the implementation of respect for indigenous rights. We have identified that at a minimum, companies need to have human rights due diligence processes in place, conduct human rights impact assessments at the site or project level and commit to respect the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.
Diving deeper
What other information can investors ask from investee companies, particularly those in the extractives and energy sectors, to understand how robust their public commitments to respecting indigenous rights are in practice? Here are ten questions we have found helpful in our own engagements with companies:
-
How are concerns from affected communities escalated to the top, and does senior management and the board have responsibility for and oversight of indigenous relationships?
-
What type of expert advice does the board and senior management take into account to inform them of good practice, such as an external advisory committee consisting of indigenous representatives?
-
How does the company identify indigenous persons and how does it discern what constitutes customary, ancestry, or collective land, territories, cultural heritage and resources in each project area?
-
How often is FPIC reviewed and renewed? What is the company’s contingency plan if FPIC wasn’t granted, or would the company still proceed as usual assuming FPIC is a soft requirement? Once agreements between the company and communities or titleholders are signed, how does the company ensure there is ongoing project-based consultation and consent?
-
What does the company and the community define as consent, and with whom has consent been secured? Are there any groups (neighbouring, or otherwise) which have not consented?
-
Do the contracts contain any elements that would prohibit titleholders from speaking out publicly in cases of discontent?
-
Is the company able to provide transparency into contracts with indigenous communities or disclose them in full, and if not, why? (i.e. a good reason would be that the indigenous communities do not want contracts to be made public)
-
Can the company provide insight into grievance cases and the actions it has taken to provide remedy?
-
How does the company work with the local authority to respect indigenous rights when lands are not officially titled to the local indigenous groups?
-
How does the company incorporate benefits-sharing with communities explicitly into its projects?
Final thoughts
With any best practice related to minimising harm of affected people, what constitutes robust FPIC and a good relationship with indigenous communities should be informed by what indigenous communities themselves identify as being best practice.
Interested in learning more? For further reading, we would recommend:
First People’s Worldwide’s FPIC Due Diligence Questionnaire
Understanding Successful Approaches of FPIC in Canada
You might also be interested in
Why Sustainability Is Good Business: Key Takeaways from IEFA Toronto 2024
Building for Tomorrow: Real Estate, Construction, and Sustainability
A First in Western Canada: Avenue Living Leverages BMO's Retrofit Program to Add 179 New Rental Units in Downtown Edmonton
How NASA and IBM Are Using Geospatial Data and AI to Analyze Climate Risks
BMO Arranges Green Financing to Fund New Lawson Centre for Sustainability, Trinity College's Most Significant Build in a Century
BMO ranked one of the most sustainable companies in North America on the Dow Jones Sustainability Indices
Canada Has an Opportunity to Become a Global Leader in Carbon Dioxide Removal
BMO Climate Institute Business Leaders Survey: Nearly Half of Business Leaders in the U.S. and Canada Believe Climate Change Has Already Affected Their Businesses, but Few Have a Strategy
More Companies Have Plans to Address Climate Change Based on Rising Business Importance: Survey Results
How the Energy Sector Is Helping Canada Achieve Its Decarbonization Goals
Why Businesses Need to Accelerate Their Efforts to Fight Climate Change
Transforming the Global Food System to Benefit Investors and the Planet
BMO Donates $3 Million to GRID Alternatives to Provide Solar Energy Solutions for Low-Income Families
Banco do Brasil and BMO Financial Group to Introduce First-of-its-Kind Program to Provide Sustainability-Linked Trade Loans Supporting Brazilian Exporters
BMO Provides Innovative New Sustainability-Linked Deposit Product to Zurn Elkay Water Solutions
Quick Listen: Michael Torrance on Empowering Your Organization to Operationalize Sustainability
BMO and Bell Canada Execute Innovative Sustainability-Linked Derivative Tied to Ambitious GHG Emission Reduction Targets
BMO Named to UN-Convened Group Providing Guidance to Global Banks on Nature Target Setting
Driving Innovations In Tech To Strengthen Climate Resilience With Climate Engine’s Spatiafi, Built On Google Cloud
BMO Celebrates Earth Day with 3rd Annual Trees from Trades Day on its Global Trading Floors
BMO Donates $2 Million to the University of Saskatchewan to Accelerate Research Critical to the Future of Food
North America’s Critical Minerals Advantage: Deep Dive on Community Engagement
Exploring North America’s Critical Minerals Advantage: Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference
The Most Valuable Commodity is Trust: ICMM to BMO Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference
Rock Legends Reflect on Mining Hits and Misses: Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference
BMO Experts at our 32nd Global Metals, Mining & Critical Minerals Conference
Evolving Mining for a Sustainable Energy Transition: ICMM CEO Rohitesh Dhawan in Conversation
Public Policy and the Energy Transition: Howard Learner in Conversation
Taskforce on Nature-Related Financial Disclosure (TNFD) – A Plan for Integrating Nature into Business
Takeaways from the BMO Climate Institute Small and Mid-Sized Businesses Climate Survey
BMO Ranked North America's Most Sustainable Bank by Corporate Knights for Fourth Consecutive Year
Is Green Financing for Nuclear the Next Frontier in the Energy Transition?
BMO ranked one of the most sustainable companies in North America on the Dow Jones Sustainability Indices
BMO Climate Institute Survey Shows Costs and Competing Priorities Slowing Climate Action for Small and Mid-Sized Businesses
Managing and Monetizing Your Transition to a Net Zero World with BMO and Radicle
BMO the Top Ranked Financial Institution on New Global Sustainability Benchmark Announced at COP 27
COP27 in Focus: Will Energy Security and Economic Uncertainty Impact the Climate Transition?
BMO to Invest in Innovative Carbon Offsets from CarbonCure to Permanently Store CO2
RoadMap Project: An Indigenous-led Paradigm Shift for Economic Reconciliation
A Canadian First: BMO and Concordia University Partner for a Sustainable Future with Innovative Sustainability-Linked Loan
Sustainability Strategy and Reporting for Small and Medium Sized Companies: A Discussion at the Conference of Montreal
BMO to Acquire Calgary-based Radicle Group Inc., a Leader in Environmental Services
Investment Opportunities for a Net-Zero Economy: A Conversation at the Milken Institute Global Conference
How Hope, Grit, and a Hospital Network Saved Maverix Private Capital Founder John Ruffolo
Hydrogen’s Role in the Energy Transition: Matt Fairley in Conversation
Exploring the Physical and Transition Risks Facing Food and Agriculture
Key Takeaways on Ag, Food, Fertilizer & ESG from BMO’s Farm to Market Conference
Building an ESG Business Case in the Food Sector: The Food Institute
Forging Ahead in the Energy Transition: Darryl White to Global Reserve and Asset Managers
BMO and EDC Announce Collaboration to Introduce Sustainable Finance Solutions for Canadian Businesses
Retrofitting Canada's Building Sector: Efficiency Canada’s Corey Diamond in Conversation
The Role of Hydrogen in the Energy Transition: FuelCell Energy CEO Jason Few in Conversation
BMO proud to support first Government of Canada Green Bond transaction as joint-lead manager
Tackling Climate Change in Metals and Mining: ICMM CEO Rohitesh Dhawan in Conversation
Op Ed: Government Action Can Help Spur More Home Building To Address Canada’s Housing Shortage
BMO Launches Business Within Reach: BMO for Black Entrepreneurs and Commits $100 million in loans to Help Black-led Businesses Start up, Scale up, and Grow
The Post 2020 Biodiversity Framework – A Discussion with Basile Van Havre
BMO Announces Plan to Partner with Breakthrough Energy Catalyst to Accelerate Climate Innovation
BMO Financial Group Named North America's Most Sustainable Bank for Third Consecutive Year
Mitigating the Physical Impacts of Climate Change with Spatial Finance
BMO Helps Boralex Go Beyond Renewable Energy, with the Transition of its Credit Facility to a Sustainability-Linked Loan
A Global First: BMO Supports Bruce Power with World's First Nuclear Green Financing Framework
BMO ranked one of the most sustainable companies in the world according to Dow Jones Sustainability Indices
The Future of Remote Work and Diversity in the Asset Management Industry
North American Metals & Mining first: BMO helps Sandstorm Gold Royalties achieve ESG goals with Sustainability-Linked Loan
Education, Employment and Economic Empowerment: BMO Releases Wîcihitowin ᐑᒋᐦᐃᑐᐏᐣ- First Annual Indigenous Partnerships and Progress Report
BMO Announces $12 Billion Financing Commitment towards Affordable Housing in Canada
In support of Canada’s bid to host the headquarters of the International Sustainability Standards Board
BMO supports Canada's bid to host the headquarters of the International Sustainability Standards Board
BMO Named to Canada's Best 50 Corporate Citizens Ranking by Corporate Knights
A North American First: BMO Helps Gibson Energy Fully Transition Credit Facility to a Sustainability-Linked Loan
Understanding Biodiversity Management: Best Practices and Innovation
Episode 29: What 20 Years of ESG Engagement Can Teach Us About the Future
BMO Financial Group 2020 Sustainability Report and Public Accountability Statement Now Available Online
Episode 28: Bloomberg: Enhancing ESG Disclosure through Data-Driven Solutions
BMO Ranked Among Most Sustainable Companies on Dow Jones Sustainability Index - North America
BMO investing in a sustainable future with $1M donation to the Institute for Sustainable Finance
BMO Financial Group Reaches Key Milestone in Matching 100 Per Cent of Electricity Usage with Renewables
BMO Financial Group Recognized as One of the World's Most Sustainably Managed Companies in New Wall Street Journal Ranking
Episode 23: TC Transcontinental – A Market Leader in Sustainable Packaging
BMO Financial Group to Source 100 Per Cent of Electricity Usage From Renewables
Episode 07: World Bank: Mobilizing Capital Markets for Sustainable Finance
Episode 06: Responsible Investing – Industry Trends and Best Practices from Canada